👋Hi! I'm Molly. This is where I share the lessons I’ve learned from building fast-moving, messy, ambitious companies. For more from me, you can also find me on the WorkLife Podcast, on LinkedIn, and in Glue Club, a community for leaders who care about building great companies.
We’ve all been there. You’re in the final stages with a candidate you’re excited about. They’re strong, they’re eager, and they could really move the needle. But then comes the ask:
“I need assurance I’ll always be the most senior person in this function.”
“I need to know that you won’t ever hire above me.”
“I want the CXO title, otherwise I’m out.”
In that moment, it’s tempting to cave. You’re desperate to close them. The ask feels small compared to the risk of losing them. And if you just say yes, the problem feels like it goes away.
Except it doesn’t. It just gets deferred. Claire Hughes Johnson came to speak to Glue Club recently, and as always, she left us with a lot to think about. But she had this one metaphor that has really stuck with me. She was talking about the reasons why she, Patrick, and John tried not to use titles or job scope in recruiting: “Giving out inflated titles or scope too early is like mailing yourself a letter bomb. It feels like you solved the problem in the moment, but a year later it explodes.”
It’s brilliant. Anyone who has done this (or experienced it on the employee side) knows viscerally what she is talking about. Promising someone something that you can’t control (because you don’t truly know what the future of your company or the team will require) is essentially like mailing yourself a letter bomb — and someday, it’s going to explode in your face.
Be Clear (and Relatively Unapologetic) About What You Can’t Control
Inside Glue Club, I talk a lot about this as a cardinal rule of management when you are building teams inside of growing companies: don’t promise things you can’t control.
Change is one of the only constant things inside a startup (of any shape and size). And being a manager inside a startup means that you both have to manage your own emotional rollercoaster, and you are ALSO responsible for helping your team manage theirs. Said more bluntly, you have to keep your shit together while handling everyone else’s meltdowns.
I have found it extremely important in these roles to be VERY clear and (relatively) unapologetic about the things you can’t control — with yourself but also with your team. “I cannot control that” is a sentence that can have a lot of power. There are a LOT of things you can’t control.
You cannot control the chaos or the rate of change.
You cannot control the fact that people’s jobs are growing and changing all the time.
You cannot control if the business will be successful.
You cannot control if someone’s growth can keep up with the company's growth.
You cannot control if everyone will “make it” — some people will fail, and that’s ok.
Let go of the idea that you’re supposed to be able to solve all the problems or have all the answers. You are not.
In a fast-growing company, you can’t control who gets promoted when. You can’t guarantee that you’ll never need to hire someone more senior. You can’t meet everyone’s compensation demands or win every counteroffer. When you try to offer that kind of certainty, you’re not giving someone stability — you’re giving them a countdown timer.
And when the bomb goes off? Trust is destroyed. Employees feel betrayed, leadership looks inconsistent, and culture takes the hit.
There is NO FASTER WAY to demoralize a high performer or a great leader than promising something and then going back on it.
Sell What Doesn’t Change
What you can control is expectations. You can tell candidates:
“Here’s what I can promise you: big challenges, growth opportunities, and the chance to work with incredible people.”
“Here’s what I can’t promise you: the exact shape of your role six months from now.”
That honesty won’t prevent every disappointment, but it prevents betrayal. And betrayal is what causes the real damage.
And as a manager, you can actually commit to and control ensuring that people are challenged and growing inside your company. Even inside a company that ISN’T growing you can still find individual growth paths for high performers that will challenge them and move them forward in their career. You can promise growth and challenge; you cannot promise that the walls and the ceiling will be in the same place 6 months from now…
Claire shared another smart lesson from Stripe: she and Patrick didn’t sell job descriptions or titles. They sold Stripe itself — the mission, the vision, the size of the opportunity.
Because titles change, scopes change, reporting lines change, but the company’s ambition, its reason for existing: that’s the constant. If people join for that, they’ll weather the inevitable shifts with you.
If someone is hung up on titles, comp, or guarantees you can’t honestly give — even if they’re a high performer, even if they seem like a unicorn candidate — sometimes it’s best just to let them walk. But it is ALWAYS best to be honest and direct with them about what you cannot promise or commit to, because getting someone to stay for the wrong reasons is a letter bomb. It will explode in the future, and you will regret it.
The Painful Story
A friend of mine once worked at a company where the CEO committed the ultimate version of this mistake.
They had a strong, tenured employee that they wanted to reward, so they tried them in the CXO role. The person failed, which isn’t an uncommon story. Amazing ICs do not always (or often) make amazing leaders. Instead of communicating that clearly and handling the change directly, the CEO slid them back into an IC seller role, but didn’t change their title or their compensation. The CEO effectively managed the transition without any direct and real conversations in order to avoid short term discomfort.
The terrifying version of this letter bomb: that employee was mad about something related, rallied a bunch of the team, got the board involved, and eventually gathered enough momentum in their revolt that they actually managed to push the CEO out.
Talk about a letter bomb.
The Real Guarantee
I have been on both sides of a letter bomb — promising someone something that I couldn’t control and having it explode on me, and having promises made to me that destroyed my trust with someone who recruited me. Both sides are terrible.
It’s tempting to trade short-term peace for long-term pain. I’ve done it. Everyone I know who’s built something at scale has done it. But the real guarantee you can offer — the only one that actually holds up — is growth and the big, company-level opportunity.
Growth of the company. Growth of the problems. Growth of the people who are up for the ride. Those are the things to focus on and to commit to.
Everything else? Handle with care.
What else?
If this resonates for you, here are things you can do next:
Subscribe to Lessons to get new posts. I post at least 2X per month for all, and paid subscribers also get access to video courses and the full library of content.
Listen to the WorkLife podcast, where I talk to brilliant leaders and builders to untangle the messy, human side of work.
Follow me on LinkedIn, where I share more tools, thoughts, and a little of the day-to-day chaos.
And if you’re a leader looking for a community of peers to lean on and learn from, come find out more about Glue Club over here.

